The netsuke's form is unusual. The creature clasps its feet with its hands and stretches its almost non-existent neck upwards, apparently straining to look at the sky. The face is a tour de force of minute relief carving. Seen from the side, the depth of the carving becomes especially apparent; so, too, does the creature's predicament. Given the position of its body and the deeply recessed placement of its eyes, it seems destined, however hard it tries, to see little more than the underside of its own brow.
The head is formed from a small group of smooth mounds, flanked by tufts of hair that rest against the shoulders and back. Stippling covers the body, appearing most clearly in areas protected from handling and natural wear, particularly between the hair tufts. This suggests that the surface decoration may originally have been more extensive. The creature wears only a loincloth, edged with a border at the waist. The himotoshi is of chimney form; around the exit hole, positioned within the loincloth, are traces of a signature that is unfortunately no longer legible.
Even after examining many netsuke, it is unusual to find one whose subject remains so difficult to identify. Yet, both when acquiring this example and during the research that followed, I have found myself unable to reach a firm conclusion about its classification.
Some may classify the creature as an oni. Although I understand that interpretation, I remain unconvinced. It is certainly otherworldly and oni-like, but its precise identity is far from clear.
My research led me to consider the Yokai known as the Yamabiko, a subject possibly carved by Kokei. Mang Collection Quinn's Auction Gallery, 7 December 2012, lot 250. It is possible that our anonymous carver drew on the Yamabiko as a starting point for this distinctive interpretation, although the identification must remain tentative.
I have always been drawn to netsuke depicting the otherworldly. This example's fine workmanship, unusual form and elusive folkloric identity give it an appeal that is difficult to quantify. For many collectors, a point comes when the pursuit of canonical subjects gives way to a different ambition: to find works that are genuinely unusual and, in practical terms, irreplaceable. This netsuke belongs to that category. Whatever its ultimate identification, I believe it would be a core piece in almost any collection I have had the opportunity to examine.
What I am a little more convinced of is who potentially made the netsuke. Mototada or Tomohisa, masters more commonly found to have worked in antler.
Signed, but illegible. Attributed to Mototada/Tomohisa, please follow the link for details.